Benton Fine Jewelry
  • Home
  • Jewelry
  • Repairs & Services
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Jewelry
    • Repairs & Services
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
Benton Fine Jewelry
  • Home
  • Jewelry
  • Repairs & Services
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

GENERATIONS OF FINE JEWElrY & SERVICE

GENERATIONS OF FINE JEWElrY & SERVICEGENERATIONS OF FINE JEWElrY & SERVICEGENERATIONS OF FINE JEWElrY & SERVICE

Your Neighborhood Jeweler Since 1952

OUR LEGACY

Since 1952, families in Southern Indiana and Louisville have trusted us for beautiful jewelry, expert repairs, and personal care you can count on. As a family-owned business now in its third generation, we’re proud to serve the community with honesty, craftsmanship, and a deep commitment to every customer who walks through our door.


Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, repairing a family heirloom, or simply stopping in to browse, we’re here to help, no appointment needed.

SHOP OUR JEWELRY COLLECTION

Engagement rings & wedding bands

Colored stones: sapphire, emerald, ruby, garnet, and more

Gold and sterling silver chains, pendants, baby jewelry

Right-hand rings and custom orders

overnight special orders via Quality Gold

Looking for something specific? We can order multiple styles overnight and help you compare them in person. 

Explore Our Jewelry

Jewelry Repairs & Services

 Service is where we shine. Whether it’s a quick fix or a careful restoration, we offer: 

Ring sizing, clasp and chain repair, watch batteries

Ring sizing, clasp and chain repair, watch batteries

Ring sizing, clasp and chain repair, watch batteries

Prong checks & professional cleaning, free

Ring sizing, clasp and chain repair, watch batteries

Ring sizing, clasp and chain repair, watch batteries

In-house engraving for jewelry and gifts

Ring sizing, clasp and chain repair, watch batteries

In-house engraving for jewelry and gifts

Informal jewelry evaluations

Appraisals for diamond jewelry

In-house engraving for jewelry and gifts

(real vs. costume)

Appraisals for diamond jewelry

Appraisals for diamond jewelry

Appraisals for diamond jewelry

You’ll always get free estimates, honest advice, and expert care, even if you didn’t buy the piece from us. 

View Repairs & Services

Giftware & Keepsakes

Celebrate life’s special moments with our collection of clocks, trinket boxes, baby gifts, and more. Most are engravable.
Perfect for weddings, anniversaries, and meaningful milestones. 

WHY PEOPLE TRUST BENTON FINE JEWELRY

For over 70 years, we’ve built our reputation on honesty, craftsmanship, and treating every customer like family. Here’s why so many families across generations continue to choose us: 

Family-Owned Since 1952

A trusted name passed down through generations - and still run by the Benton family today. 

No-Pressure, Personal Service

We believe in honest advice and helping you make the right choice - not the most expensive one. 

Trusted Repairs with Free Estimates

Whether it's a simple fix or a sentimental restoration, you'll always get clear pricing and careful work. 

Generations of Loyal Customers

Many of our customers have been with us for decades - and now bring their children and grandchildren. 

We Stand Behind Our Work

All purchases come with a 90-day warranty, and we offer half-price repairs on items bought from our store. 

Explore More Styles

Looking for something beyond what’s in-store? 

Browse jewelry collections from some of our trusted manufacturers below. While you can’t purchase directly from these sites, you can explore styles and then call or stop in to ask about pricing, availability, or to place an order. We’re happy to help! 

Stuller

Generations of Fine Jewelry & Service

Visit our store in downtown Jeffersonville, let us help with your next piece, repair, or special occasion. 

Benton Fine Jewelry

135 West Court Avenue, Jeffersonville, IN, USA

812-284-3389

Hours

Open today

10:00 am – 05:30 pm

Leave Us A Message

Attach Files
Attachments (0)

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Cancel

Copyright © 2025 Benton Fine Jewelry - All Rights Reserved.

website designed by so in media group

  • Stuller
  • Quality Gold
  • Unique Settings
  • Rembrandt Charms

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept